Distress in commercial real estate is permanent. It doesn't appear and disappear with economic cycles. It shifts in density and location depending on what's happening in the market. During difficult economic periods, distress becomes more visible and more widespread. But even in strong markets, deals go bad regularly and quietly.
Understanding what causes distress serves two purposes. It makes you a better evaluator of risk. And it helps you recognize where exceptional opportunities come from, because distressed situations are often where the best basis is found.
Here are the seven main reasons good commercial real estate deals go bad.
Weak Operator
The operator is the single most common cause of a deal going sideways. They are responsible for sourcing the opportunity, securing financing, and managing everything required to execute the business plan, from day-to-day operations to the critical events that determine whether the deal performs. A weak operator can take a great asset in a great market and still lose. Evaluating the operator is where due diligence starts and ends.
Time
Time is the most underappreciated risk factor in private real estate. A project that gets dragged along through permitting delays, construction overruns, slow lease-up, or a market that shifts mid-execution will erode returns even when everything else goes right. Deals are underwritten to a timeline. When that timeline breaks, the math changes.
Underestimated Costs
Cost overruns are one of the most common ways deals deteriorate. Whether the result of poor due diligence, optimistic underwriting, or unexpected site conditions, underestimating what it actually costs to execute a business plan creates a capital gap that typically falls on equity. Conservative underwriting and the right third-party professionals at the front end are what control this risk.
Key Events
Every deal has a set of events that must occur for the business plan to succeed: entitlement, construction completion, rehab, lease-up, tenant renewals, refinancing. Each of those events carries its own probability of failure. The more key events a deal depends on, the more ways it can go wrong. Understanding what needs to happen, in what sequence, and what the backup plan is if it doesn't, is essential before committing capital.
Overleveraged Property
Leverage amplifies both returns and risk. When key events fail or timelines stretch, the debt doesn't wait. A property that was appropriately levered at acquisition can become overleveraged quickly if income doesn't materialize on schedule or if values soften. The capital structure needs to be stress-tested against realistic downside scenarios, not just the base case.
Market Conditions Change
Even a well-executed business plan can be undermined by a market that shifts underneath it. Softening demand, new supply entering the submarket, tightening credit conditions, or a change in the tenant base can all affect a deal's performance regardless of how well the operator is executing. Market selection is risk management.
Interest Rate Environment
Interest rates have a direct impact on commercial real estate from multiple directions. Floating rate debt becomes more expensive when rates rise. Refinancing assumptions get blown up when the rate environment at exit looks nothing like it did at acquisition. And cap rates tend to expand when rates stay elevated, compressing valuations even on assets that are performing operationally. Deals underwritten without stress-testing the rate environment carry more risk than most investors realize.
The Bottom Line
Good real estate deals can go bad. And when they do, there is usually a story that goes along with it. A good friend once called this the "Country Music Story" because it usually ends with some kind of heartbreak.
Understanding why deals go bad is how you learn to read risk before you commit capital. It's also how you develop the discipline to pass on deals that look attractive on the surface but carry structural problems underneath.
The nine fundamentals below are what every passive investor should evaluate before moving forward with any private CRE investment. Each one maps directly to a failure point above.
- Operator
- Market
- Asset
- Basis
- Business Plan
- Debt
- Equity
- Capital Sources and Uses
- Waterfall
Download the P10 9-Point Checklist to see how each of these should be evaluated before you invest. Get the Checklist
Want to stay connected on what Pillar 10 is watching in the market? Join the P10 Club.